Is It Who You Are or Where You Live? Residential Segregation and Racial Gaps in Childhood Asthma
ABSTRACT: Higher asthma rates are one of the more obvious ways that health inequalities between African American and other children are manifested beginning in early childhood. In 2010, black asthma rates were double non-black rates. Some but not all of this difference can be explained by factors such as a higher incidence of low birth weight (LBW) among blacks; however, even conditional on LBW, blacks have a higher incidence of asthma than others. Using a unique data set based on the health records of all children born in New Jersey between 2006 and 2010, we show that when we split the data by whether or not children live in a “black” zip code, this racial difference in the incidence of asthma among LBW children entirely disappears. All LBW children in these zip codes, regardless of race, have a higher incidence of asthma. Our results point to the importance of residential segregation and neighborhoods in explaining persistent racial health disparities. Read the RESEARCH BRIEF below.
Researchers have had trouble explaining why black children are much more likely than other children to suffer from asthma. A new study by Princeton University strongly suggests that much of the answer lies in persistent residential segregation, which traps minority children in unhealthy, polluted neighborhoods.
In the United States, black children are twice as likely as other children to develop asthma. Past research has attributed some of this difference to low birth weight, as black children are also more likely than others to be born at a low weight — defined as less than 2,500 grams, or about 5.5 pounds — and low birth weight is a risk factor for developing asthma.
Yet even when comparing only low-birth-weight children, said Janet M. Currie, who is the Henry Putnam Professor of Economics and Public Affairs, black children are still more likely to develop asthma. The racial disparity in asthma rates is so strong that some researchers have even concluded that “being black” is a risk factor for asthma.
But when Currie and her co-author, Princeton Ph.D. Diane Alexander of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, compared low-birth-weight children of all races and ethnicities who lived in “black” ZIP codes in New Jersey — in which half or more of the residents are African American — the racial disparity in the association between low birth weight and asthma disappeared completely. In other words, all low-birth-weight children in these ZIP codes, whatever their race, had the same elevated risk of asthma, compared to children born at a normal weight.
Low birth weight may predispose children to asthma, but by itself it doesn’t cause the disease. A physical trigger is required. Thus it appears that something about the neighborhoods where the low-birth-weight children live, regardless of their race, is causing them to develop asthma. “This distinction is important,” Currie said, “because unlike race, it is possible to change neighborhoods, either by finding and remediating the hazards that are causing higher asthma prevalence or by helping vulnerable children to move.”
Currie and Alexander’s study couldn’t say definitively what exactly about the neighborhoods in “black” ZIP codes is triggering asthma in low-birth-weight children. But they speculated that air pollution — both indoor and outdoor — is to blame.
New Jersey neighborhoods with a majority of black residents are on average twice as close as other neighborhoods to major industrial sources of air pollution, the researchers found, and more likely to be near busy highways that produce high concentrations of harmful particulate matter. Housing in these neighborhoods is on average seven years older than elsewhere, and older buildings are more likely to harbor mold spores and fecal matter from rodent and insect infestations. Finally, mothers in these neighborhoods are somewhat more likely to smoke indoors.
Not only can indoor and outdoor air pollution trigger asthma in susceptible children, Currie and Alexander noted — they can also cause women to have low-birth-weight babies in the first place.
To conduct their study, which appeared as a working paper on the National Bureau of Economic Research website, Currie and Alexander combined two sets of data — records of all children born to mothers who lived in New Jersey from 2006 to 2010, and records of all New Jersey hospital emergency room visits from 2006 to 2012.
Because the birth records included mothers’ addresses, they were able to see which children were born in predominately black neighborhoods, as organized by ZIP code. These ZIP codes included about 63 percent of the state’s black children, but also about 16 percent of the state’s other children. The emergency room records let the researchers determine whether or how many times each low-birth-weight child was treated in an emergency room for asthma during the study period.
“The United States continues to be highly racially segregated,” Currie said, “with African-American neighborhoods suffering higher poverty, lower average educational attainments, higher unemployment, higher exposure to pollution, and other ills.” Black Americans of any age also tend to be in worse health than their white counterparts, by any number of measures. Currie and Alexander’s study suggests that the characteristics of highly segregated neighborhoods may be a major factor behind such persistent racial health disparities.
The study, “Is It Who You Are or Where You Live? Residential Segregation and Racial Gaps in Childhood Asthma,” appeared on the NBER’s website in July 2017. As a working paper, it was not peer-reviewed or subject to the review by the NBER Board of Directors that accompanies official NBER publications. A version of the paper will appear in a forthcoming issue of the Journal of Health Economics.